Estimation: when an approximate answer is the right answer

These teaching notes are for members

What the video covers, what to say before it, where a class usually goes wrong, and what to set afterwards. An account is free, and it opens every chapter of every book.

Create a free account Sign in

What to assume they know

Rearranging a sum so it can be done in your head: regrouping a sum so it can be done in the head
Multiplication of two- and three-digit numbers, and multiplication by 10, 100, 1000
Reading a map with a scale
Units of time — minutes, hours, days — and of capacity

What they should be able to do

Say when an exact count is needed and when an estimate will do
Replace a set of awkward numbers by a single round one, and say what was assumed
Scale a small count up to a large one by multiplying
Estimate a length by pacing a short part of it and multiplying
Estimate a total over time by finding a rate for a short interval
Judge whether a number somebody else has quoted is believable, and show the working that decides it
Estimate a cost, and explain why the answer depends on choices that must be stated
Estimate a distance from a map
Frame an estimation question of your own that another student could attempt

Where it usually goes wrong

"An estimate is a wrong answer." It is an answer to a coarser question. If you want to know whether the hall will hold the school, "about 500" settles it and "497" adds nothing.
"Estimating means guessing." Paromita multiplies. Every step of her reasoning can be pointed at and disputed, which is exactly what a guess cannot offer.
"Rounding never matters." She rounds 96 up to 100 and then multiplies by five, so the rounding is multiplied too. Rounding is safe when you know which way it pushes and by how much.
"Bigger numbers need better estimates." The opposite, usually: the bigger the quantity, the coarser an answer you can live with. Estimating the length of India to the nearest kilometre would be absurd.
"There is one correct estimate." Roshan's ₹100 is defensible or not depending on which fruit and how much of it — the question is asking for the reasoning, and a bare yes or no earns nothing.
"You cannot estimate something you cannot see all of." Steps to your home, breaths in a day and the length of India are all in the exercise, and none of them can be counted directly. Each is a small measurement multiplied up.
"A big round total must be about right because it is round." Sheetal's 13,000 is round and is precisely what the question asks you to doubt.

Questions to check understanding

Estimate a quantity and show the reasoning as working
"Do you agree with this number? Why or why not?" — the chapter's own framing for Roshan and for Sheetal
Estimate a length by pacing, given the length of one pace
Estimate a total from a rate over a short interval
Estimate a distance from a map with a scale
Compare an estimate with an exact count and comment on the gap — the chapter-end holidays question (p.72) is built for this
Items asking which of two quantities is larger, where an exact computation is not available
Items asking what was assumed, and what would change the answer

Examples worth working on the board

The opening contrast (§3.11, p.69). The head of the school knows the exact enrolment; a pupil knows only about how many. The book offers three candidate sizes — about 150, about 400, about a thousand — as the kind of answer wanted.
Paromita's estimate (§3.11, p.69). Her own section holds 32 children; the other two sections of her year hold 29 and 35. She treats her whole year as about 100. Her school also runs Classes 7 to 10, three sections each, and she assumes each year is about the same size, giving about 500 for the school.
What Paromita assumed. Three things, all worth naming: that the three sections are typical; that the other year groups are the same size as hers; and that rounding 96 up to 100 will not matter once it is multiplied by five. The third is the one to interrogate — five lots of the rounding is five times the error.
Pacing (§3.11, p.70, question 1). Four distances of very different sizes: to the classroom door, across the school ground, to the school gate, and home. Only the first is directly countable; the rest need the first as a unit.
Rates (§3.11, p.70, question 2). Blinks or breaths in a minute, then in an hour, then in a day.
The quick-guess items (§3.11, pp.70–71). Words in the maths textbook, more or less than 5000; pupils travelling by bus, more or less than 200; Roshan's ₹100 fruit custard for five people; the distance from Gandhinagar in Gujarat to Kohima in Nagaland, with the hint to find both on a map of India.
Sheetal's claim (§3.11, p.71, question 5). Her figure for the time she has so far spent at school is about 13,000 hours. The check is a three-factor multiplication — school hours in a day, school days in a year, years of school so far. Whether 13,000 is believable depends entirely on the three numbers chosen, and saying so is the point of the question.
Walking times (§3.11, p.71, question 6). Somewhere nearby, a neighbouring state's capital, and the whole length of India from the southernmost point to the northernmost. Three scales, the same method.
Capacity and holidays (chapter-end Figure it Out, p.72, questions 4 and 5). Question 4 asks for a year's worth of days off — weekends, festival days and the long vacation all counted — and then for the true figure, so that the two can be set against each other. Question 5 asks how many litres each of three containers holds: a mug, a bucket, and a tank on the roof. The first of these is the only place in the chapter where an estimate is explicitly checked against a true value.

Figures to have open

A map of India with Gandhinagar and Kohima marked and a visible scale bar. The textbook prints no map here — it tells the student to find one — so this must be supplied. Standard schematic; the scale bar is the part that does the work.
A three-factor multiplication frame with blanks, for Sheetal's check. Standard schematic.
A school-structure diagram: one section, three sections to a year, five years to a school. Standard schematic, not in the textbook.
No table, dataset or photograph from the textbook is required; §3.11 prints running text and question lists only.

Where this sits in the book

NCERT Class 6 Mathematics (Ganita Prakash), Chapter 3 "Number Play": §3.11 Simple Estimation, pp.69–71
The opening contrast between an exact and an estimated count, p.69
Paromita's worked estimate, p.69
The Figure it Out block, questions 1–3, p.70
The bold sub-heading Estimate the answer and its questions 1–4 on p.70, and questions 5–7 on p.71
The chapter-end Figure it Out block, p.72, questions 4 and 5
Summary, p.73, where estimating magnitudes is named as one of the chapter's uses of number
Backward link: §3.8, pp.65–67 (Rearranging a sum so it can be done in your head), for the regrouping habit this section spends